Reed Relays and
Electronics India Limited
Manufacturer of Reed Switches, Reed Sensors and Reed-based products
Reed Relays and Electronics India Limited Incorporated in 1971

Physical Modifications of Reed Switches

Modification of Reed Switch leads should be undertaken with the utmost care so as to not damage the glass seal or compromise the hermetic seals. Some information pertaining to this is given below. Click here to  download this page as a PDF.

Cropping

Cropping the leads of a reed switch removes low reluctance iron and introduces high reluctance air into the magnetic circuit, much the same as adding resistance to an electrical circuit. The result is that a greater number of equivalent Operate AT is required to close a cropped reed switch. Cropping also increases the release AT. It is recommended that end nippers be used, rather than conventional wire cutters, which may produce as much as 70g shock in the seal area.
Reed Switch cropped with wire cutter
For miniature reed switches with glass diameter less than 2.0 mm, even end nippers may cause microscopic seal damage, and clamping the area between the seal and the cropping point is recommended before cropping
Reed Switch cropped with end nipper

Forming

Many of the same rules that pertain to cropping also apply to forming. Stops or guides that use the end of the seal as a reference point for forming can damage the hermetic seals. Also, using the seal as a dimensional reference point invariably results in variation of the lead dimensions after forming.
Reed Switch cropped with cropping tool
The recommended practice is to use the lead ends as a reference. Support must be provided between the seal and the forming point. A clamping device is usually recommended because as the lead is bent, stress must not be transferred to the seal area. This approach also allows for normal variations in glass length and distance between seal and each lead end.
Reed Switch formed with forming tool

Welding and Soldering

In some instances, neither cropping nor forming can provide the required lead configuration, and welding or soldering additional material to the leads is the only answer. The leads of a standard reed switch are composed of approximately 50% nickel and 50% iron. These leads are plated after assembly with either gold or tin to improve weldability and solderability. Welding is preferred to soldering because less heat travels to the seal area. The coefficients of thermal expansion of the leads and glass are closely matched, but welding and soldering heat the wire more quickly than the glass. The result is that metal expansion can loosen or crack the glass-to-metal seal. Properly heat-sinked welding fixture and optimized welding cycles can produce strong bonds without seal degradation.

Dimensioning

Illustrated are two methods for dimensioning the same modification. The left illustration presents an impossible situation mainly because the glass length and its position relative to the gap vary greatly between switches. Compared to the precise dimensions of the reeds, it is unadvisable to use the envelope as a reference point. A common error is stacking three dimensions to come up with a toleranced overall length. This is quite an accomplishment especially when one dimension is specified as max.
Wrong Reed Switch dimensioning
The following figure has all the necessary dimensions referenced either from the air gap or the reed, both of which can be held with close tolerances. The bends are set up equally from the magnetic centre of the reed switch, which is located at the air gap. If a magnet is used for actuation, the operating point for reed switches with the same Operate AT will be uniform. A switch dimensioned in this manner can have leads cut and formed in one operation. The number of measurements required to inspect the modified switch is minimized.
Correct Reed Switch dimensioning

Summary
Article Name
Modification of Reed Switches
Author
Description
Pracautions and points to remember when physically modifying reed switches by cropping, soldering or welding.

Leave a Reply